-Court Says Police Used Excessive Force in 2015 Death

Court Says Police Used Excessive Force in 2015 Death

A federal appeals court has ruled that Honolulu police officers used excessive force in the 2015 death of Sheldon Haleck, clearing the way for a lawsuit to proceed against the department and officers.

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals sided with a lower court ruling that the actions of the Honolulu Police Department in the March 16, 2015 arrest and eventual death of Haleck could not keep them from being sued.

The case started with a civil rights lawsuit filed by Haleck’s family against the City and County of Honolulu and three police officers. It accused officers Christopher Chung, Samantha Critchlow and Stephen Kardash of using excessive force when trying to arrest Haleck, who was seen darting through traffic near Iolani Palace.

Haleck, 38, was first sprayed with pepper spray, then tased. More pepper spray was used and officers then tackled him to the ground. He was eventually restrained by several officer who shackled his arms and legs Officers held him down so they could shackle his arms and legs.

Haleck was unresponsive when officers turned him over, according to his autopsy report. He died the next day at Queens Medical Center.

The police department countered in federal court that the officers had used appropriate police tactics and had a right to qualified immunity. The lower federal district court disagreed, sending the case to the Ninth Circuit and putting the family’s suit in a holding pattern until this decision.

“Although Appellants were serving in a caretaking function, there was no emergency to increase the ‘severity’ of the circumstances,” the decision from the 9th Circuit Court on Tuesday stated. “We affirm the district court’s denial of qualified immunity and remand for further proceedings consistent with this disposition.”

A medical examiner report ruled his death a homicide that was due to “multiple metabolic and cardiac complications” stemming from what was described as a “violent physical struggle” with police. The autopsy also revealed Haleck had taken a methamphetamine.

There was no immediate comment from the Honolulu Police Department about the ruling. Attorney Eric Seitz, who represents the Haleck family said the ruling allows the lawsuit to proceed.

“They’ve been wrong, horribly wrong on this case,” Seitz said of HPD.

In Honolulu, home to Hawaii’s largest police department, patrol cars are not equipped with dashcam video and body cameras are not expected to be issued to officers until later this year.

Only police Tasers are equipped with cameras. Four months after Civil Beat first asked for the video from the Taser, it was released by HPD.

In the video, Haleck appears to have his hands up and talking to officers before they used the Taser.


By: ThisIsButter (20649.50)

Tags: wtf

Location: Honolulu

Liveleak on Facebook


33 dating a 22 year old best free dating wordpress theme conoce chicas en internet flensburg singletreff best paid indian dating sites free dating website australia cod aw bad matchmaking best free dating sites adelaide meilleur site de rencontre gratuit 2012 assembly of god view on dating singles hall and oates my best friend is dating someone i don't like good opening message online dating online dating site for anime fans matchmaking terms and conditions conocer chicas en rd single de was ist kostenlos good opening lines internet dating gratis datingsider på nett mainz singlebörse how to deal with girl dating other guys dating a deaf person single völkermarkt mobile dating apps for android dating agency in kiev speed dating over 50 montreal dating oslo gratis uses of mass spectrometry radioactive dating dating deggendorf dating always initiating contact wohlhabender mann sucht frau online dating in western australia lahr single party best dating profile ever pictures